
Try one of the other two offerings if you’re looking to switch things up a bit and are willing to pay for a a slightly higher (yet still affordable) price point. Both have the same utility as the flagship when it comes to an Old Fashioned. Keep a bottle of Bulleit in your cabinet and you’ll be able to mix perfectly acceptable Old Fashioneds whenever you want.Īlso worth noting are the two upscale bourbon offerings from Bulleit: a 10-year-old and a barrel strength. But that’s all part of what makes it a go-to option for an Old Fashioned. Regardless of what direction you’re looking to take your Old Fashioned, there’s a bourbon that will take you there.īulleit isn’t going to revolutionize American bourbon and it’s never going to be the greatest bourbon you ever drink. For example, a bourbon with a high rye mash bill will lead to an Old Fashioned that’s more similar to the cocktail’s original recipe, while a higher percentage of corn typically results in a sweeter cocktail. That said, there are some variations that you’ll find depending on what you use. In fact, early bartenders listed the ingredients of cocktails as spirits, bitters, water, and bit of sugar in them. That means the easiest, most honest, and least pretentious answer to the question of what bourbon makes the best Old Fashioned is: your favorite bourbon makes the best Old Fashioned. Kentucky - A quality Kentucky Straight Bourbon, aged a minimum of 5 years, that captures the American spirit. Add a little ice to cut down on the heat, add a few bitters they were often considered the medicines of the time. Assuming those things are true, you’re moving into matters of personal taste. The truth is, If the whiskey was made of high quality grain in a controlled environment by people who know what they’re doing, it’s probably a good whiskey. Too many whiskey drinkers think there’s some kind of objective hierarchy to bourbon, where people get condemned as having bad taste for drinking one brand and they’re whiskey experts if they’ve ever sniffed a bottle of another. What Bourbon Makes the Best Old Fashioned? The success of your bourbon Old Fashioned, however, largely relies on your bottle choice. If anything, it makes the cocktail a little more widely appealing, since there are some people who are driven off somewhat by rye’s characteristic bite. But even if that’s where the Old Fashioned started, ending up in bourbon territory isn’t a terrible shift. A few of our favorite bottles for when it’s time to branch out.

For someone getting into bourbon, I’d recommend the Wilderness. Sörine Anderson, Bar Manager, Bar Blondeau, Brooklyn. Bourbon Amaretto Sour – This is a must-try! The bourbon and amaretto blend so well together in this unique bourbon cocktail.Yes, the Old Fashioned was originally made with rye whiskey (and for Wisconsinites, brandy has long been the spirit of choice). So, just ask your bartender for a recommendation and imbibe.There’s a great balance between the bitters and a sugar cube. It has subtle flavors and a smooth finish. Bourbon Margarita – Our riff on the classic margarita. The best bourbon to mix into an old fashion is Basil Hayden.

15 Tried & True Bourbon Cocktails – Find all of our Bourbon Cocktails including recipes that use bourbon as an ingredient.

The warming (or burning) sensation as the whiskey goes down is called a “Kentucky Hug” when drinking bourbon. I do love my bourbon during the Fall and Winter.

Swap out simple syrup for 1 sugar cube and muddle.Simple syrup: Use store-bought simple syrup or make your own at home.Even though I talk about the Infinity Bottle in this Old Fashioned Recipe Post we drink our Infinity bottle neat. These are the ingredients youll need to make this top-rated old fashioned recipe: Get recipe of this with bourbon Old Fashioned Cocktail. You end up with a unique blended bourbon at the end. Rye Bourbon Whisky is the best to make old fashioned Cocktail. A Bourbon Infinity Bottle is where you pour your last ounce and half of your favorite bourbons into one bottle. The best bitters for an Old Fashioned are up for debate, but Angostura is classic for a reason, while Fee Brothers offer a welcome alternative.
